Death Comes to Pemberley (Book Review)

P D James’ latest detective novel is good winter reading: entertaining and easy to read (and very English – perfect with a glass of port and your feet up in front of a blazing fire.) Jane Austen fans will  know what to expect from the title: a detective story based on Pride and Prejudice.

The real pleasure of the novel is James’ re-creation of Austen’s style: her lengthy sentences and carefully-chosen vocabulary  give a convincing impression of early nineteenth – century prose. She manages this consistently, with the minor characters as well as the major ones ( Darcy, Elizabeth and Wickham):

No one expected Mary to marry. She was a compulsive reader but without discrimination or understanding, an assiduous practiser at the pianoforte but devoid of talent, and a frequent deliverer of platitudes which had neither  wisdom nor wit.

The language and the enjoyment of character-hunting ( there are references to Emma, Persuasion and Agatha Christie in Death Comes to Pemberley, as well as the cast of Pride and Prejudice) kept me reading – and made up for a less-than-convincing detective story, and for the fact that P D James’ Elizabeth is lacking in the charm and vivacity of Austen’s Lizzie Bennet (I’m afraid that marriage, motherhood and the obligations of being a Lady have made her, well, a bit boring.)

On the other hand, in terms of contemporary homage to Austen, I found this novel much more clever and entertaining than  dating manuals or  zombie sagas…

Advertisements

Comments Off on Death Comes to Pemberley (Book Review)

Filed under Book reviews

Comments are closed.